Welcome to Mighty Fine Pizza
Mighty Fine Pizza, located at 222 E Mitchell St in Petoskey, MI, is a charming eatery dedicated to serving delicious, fresh pizza. While the focus is on carryout and delivery, the outdoor seating provides a lovely ambiance for enjoying meals on warm days. Diners rave about the crunchy yet soft crust, perfectly baked breadsticks, and vibrant salads—all at an unbeatable price. Highlights include their renowned pepperoni and sausage XL pizzas, as well as unique touches like jalapeño ranch dressing. With rave reviews praising the quality and flavor, Mighty Fine Pizza truly lives up to its name, making it a must-visit for pizza lovers.
Mighty Fine Pizza: Reviews & Ratings
Not much of an interior, only outside seating. Doesn’t matter. This pizza was the best pizza I have ever had. Everything was hot and fresh, the breadsticks were perfect and the crust had a slight crunch, but was still soft. Don’t miss out.
********CARRYOUT or DELIVERY ONLY******** Apparently, I missed that detail somehow! They do have a small table out front that's probably nice when it's warm outside. The items we ordered were excellent. For the price, this place really hit the spot. Between the XL pizza, large salad, and order of breadsticks, our order was only 36. Jalapeno Ranch for the salad was a nice touch!
Cute little friendly family restaurant with no inside dining. We were happy enjoying our pizza & greek salad dinner out front with our girls (dogs). They shared a special treat of a plain burger which they loved! We really liked the burnt pizza & the sauce on it.
I ordered an XL Pizza half pepperoni half sausage. Pizza was absolutely delicious! We are visiting Petoskey from Missouri. Glad we ordered from Mighty Fine Pizza!
Sat outside and enjoyed our pizza and antipasto salad on a bright sunny day. Run—don't walk to this place and get a pizza to share with someone you love. Delicious! Inexpensive! Fabulous!
We always try the local favorite when we travel. Jacob at Hampton Inn highly recommend Mighty Fine Pizza. We followed his recommendation and were very pleased. Generous toppings and the sauce was really good. Family owned and operated. Always love to see the family involved.
There is nothing but an order counter inside so be prepared to enjoy great customer service, place your order, and have a place to eat your food once it's done. Their pizza is loaded with large chunks of fresh high quality ingredients. It tasted great and we loved it. Don't want pizza? They have more than that! Give them a try when you are nearby.
Pizza is always great, only complaint I had was asked the girls why it was 5 dollar more? I ordered the exact same thing just 2 weeks ago. Said something about a fee which makes zero sense if I had the same order. Orders the 2 topping XL special added green peppers. Paid 24 before , this time was almost 29.
Location
-
222 E Mitchell St, Petoskey, MI 49770, United States Hotline: +1 231-347-3255
Welcome to Mighty Fine Pizza, a delightful gem tucked away in Petoskey, Michigan. Nestled at 222 E Mitchell St, this eatery is quickly making a name for itself in the local pizza scene. Known for its carryout and delivery services, Mighty Fine Pizza offers a unique dining experience that encourages patrons to savor their meals in the fresh air. While the indoor seating may be limited, the inviting outdoor space amplifies the joy of enjoying a delicious meal under the sun.
First impressions matter, and it's the quality of their offerings that truly shines. A glowing review from Hayden Hogg captures the essence of Mighty Fine Pizza: “This pizza was the best pizza I have ever had.” The commitment to freshness is evident in every bite, providing a warm, crispy crust paired with delectable toppings. From the reviews, it’s clear that the breadsticks are a highlight—perfectly baked and complementing the pizza perfectly. The harmonious blend of a slight crunch with a soft insides truly enhances the texture experience, making each slice a memorable one.
For those who crave variety, the menu doesn’t disappoint. Guests can delight in an array of options, from XL pizzas loaded with toppings like pepperoni and sausage to fresh salads that bring a refreshing twist. A notable feature is the Jalapeno Ranch dressing, mentioned by B SNOW, which adds a zesty flair to their salads. It’s this attention to detail that keeps customers coming back for more.
Mighty Fine Pizza isn’t just about the food; it’s about the experience. As Amy Mueller notes, the family-friendly ambiance makes it a perfect spot for dining out with loved ones, including furry friends. Sharing a pizza and a Greek salad with family brings joy, and the satisfaction of a well-cooked meal resonates with everyone who visits.
Your taste buds will tingle with excitement at every morsel, as exemplified by Nora Roughen-Schmidt’s feast on a sunny day: “Run—don't walk to this place.” This enthusiastic endorsement speaks volumes about the quality and affordability of the offerings. Together with the pleasant outdoor seating, it creates a welcoming environment that celebrates both food and companionship.
Whether you're a local or just passing through Petoskey, Mighty Fine Pizza is an essential stop for anyone who appreciates well-crafted pizza. With each bite, you'll understand why this spot has earned its reputation as a must-visit destination. Indulge in the deliciousness that awaits and discover your new favorite pizza place!